Hawking Stuns Israel With Conference Boycott

by James M. Wall

University of Cambridge physicist Stephen Hawking stunned Israel last week with his announcement that he would boycott the fifth annual Israeli Presidential Conference, scheduled to be held in Jerusalem, June 18-20.Hawking Wikimedia Commons

Hawking was responding to an incongruity: He had been invited to attend an Israeli conference of scientific, economic and political world leaders under the lofty title: “The Human Factor in Shaping Tomorrow”.

Many usual political suspects are expected to speak at the conference, including noted Israeli friends Bill Clinton and Tony Blair.

Also listed as speakers are Stuart Eizenstat, Larry Summers and David Axelrod. George W. Bush was a speaker for the 2008 inaugural conference.

As a matter of conscience, Hawking will not be there.

What makes this conference such an incongruous event is that it will hold its “Shaping Tomorrow” sessions in close proximity to what is essentially a prison wall built to separate an occupied, entrapped Palestinian population, from the rest of the world.

Is this the future Israel would have us shape? Prison walls enforcing ethnic cleansing?

In his conference withdrawal statement Hawking (above) explained his boycott decision:

“I accepted the invitation to the Presidential Conference with the intention that this would not only allow me to express my opinion on the prospects for a peace settlement but also because it would allow me to lecture on the West Bank” 

“However, I have received a number of emails from Palestinian academics. They are unanimous that I should respect the boycott. In view of this, I must withdraw from the conference.

Had I attended, I would have stated my opinion that the policy of the present Israeli government is likely to lead to disaster”.

The term “boycott” is part of the Palestinian civil society’s Boycott, Divestment and Sanction (BDS) non-violent campaign, a grassroots movement launched in 2005 to non-violently bring an end to Israel’s occupation of Palestinian land and people.

Israel is holding its fifth conference in close proximity to the Israeli-built prison wall that enforces that occupation.

Stephen Hawking has not been known for political activism. His story unfolded in a different arena. It is a story of  his enormous personal courage and significant achievement as a physicist and cosmologist.

Hawking, who tells his personal story in “Living With ALS“, has to be the most high-profile invitee yet to boycott an Israeli Presidential conference, an event which in the past has attracted little media attention. Hawking has changed that.

In her 2012 Scientific American essay“How Has Stephen Hawking Lived to 70 with ALS?”, (on January 7, 2013, he turned 71) author Katherine Harmon provides background both on Hawking and his disease:

The famous theoretical physicist has helped to bring his ideas about black holes and quantum gravity to a broad public audience. For much of his time in the public eye, though, he has been confined to a wheelchair by a form of the motor-neuron disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). And since 1985 he has had to speak through his trademark computer system—which he operates with his cheek—and have around-the-clock care.

But like his mind, Hawking’s illness seems to be singular. Most patients with ALS—also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease, for the famous baseball player who succumbed to the disease—are diagnosed after the age of 50 and die within five years of their diagnosis. Hawking’s condition was first diagnosed when he was 21, and he was not expected to see his 25th birthday.

But his disease seems hardly to have slowed him down. Hawking spent 30 years as a full professor of mathematics at the University of Cambridge. And he is currently the director of research at the school’s Center for Theoretical Cosmology.

Hawking is the sort of high profile public figure whose boycott action is most feared by Israel.

The Guardian takes note of the blow Israel has received to its scientific prestige:

Stephen Hawking’s decision to boycott the Israeli president’s conference has gone viral. Over 100,000 Facebook shares of the Guardian report at last count. Whatever the subsequent fuss, Hawking’s letter is unequivocal. His refusal was made because of requests from Palestinian academics.

Witness the speed with which the pro-Israel lobby seized on Cambridge University’s initial false claim that he had withdrawn on health grounds to denounce the boycott movement, and their embarrassment when within a few hours the university shamefacedly corrected itself.

Hawking also made it clear that if he had gone he would have used the occasion to criticise Israel’s policies towards the Palestinians.

While journalists named him “the poster boy of the academic boycott” and supporters of the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement celebrated, Ha’aretz, the most progressive of the Israeli press, drew attention to the inflammatory language used by the conference organizers, who described themselves as “outraged” rather than that they “regretted” Hawking’s decision.

That the world’s most famous scientist had recognised the justice of the Palestinian cause is potentially a turning point for the BDS campaign. And that his stand was approved by a majority of two to one in the Guardian poll that followed his announcement shows just how far public opinion has turned against Israel’s relentless land-grabbing and oppression.

The Times of Israel made a feeble attempt to defend conference organizers.

The Times quotes Israel Maimon, chairman of the conference, who “decried” Hawking’s withdrawal as “outrageous and inappropriate, especially for one so fundamentally associated with the spirit of independence as a person and an academic.”

There is considerable irony in Israel’s promotion of its scientific achievements within strolling distance of the “prison wall” it built to deprive Palestinians of their freedom.

This is an irony made doubly painful to sensitive and compassionate Jewish Israelis when they read a description of the Conference  from their 90-year old President Peres, included in his Conference introduction:

My experience has taught me that people tend to underestimate the tremendous ability within them, and yet mankind has the power to make a difference to ensure the betterment of our collective tomorrow.

What should be more reassuring, however, to those sensitive and compassionate Jews who live under a government based on lies and deception, is a Boston Globe editorial which found Hawking’s boycott decision to be a “reasonable way to express one’s political views”.

When the esteemed physicist Stephen Hawking announced his decision to boycott Israel’s Presidential Conference, a gathering of politicians, scholars, and other high-profile figures scheduled for June, the response was as predictable as the movement of the cosmos that inspired Hawking’s career.

The conference chair, Israel Maimon, called the move “outrageous and improper,” while Omar Barghouti, a founder of the boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement that advocates protests against Israeli policies, declared, “Palestinians deeply appreciate Stephen Hawking’s support.”

In fact, the decision to withdraw from a conference is a reasonable way to express one’s political views. Observers need not agree with Hawking’s position in order to understand and even respect his choice. The movement that Hawking has signed on to aims to place pressure on Israel through peaceful means.

In the context of a Mideast conflict that has caused so much destruction and cost so many lives, nonviolence is something to be encouraged. That is equally true of attempts to inspire cooperation on the Palestinian side.

Chances for a peaceful solution in Israel and Palestine are remote enough without overreactions like Maimon’s. Foreclosing nonviolent avenues to give people a political voice — and maybe bring about an eventual resolution — only makes what is already difficult that much more challenging.

Ali Abunimah was also encouraged by Hawking’s boycott action. Abunimah writes in The Guardian:

One of the most deceptive aspects of the so-called peace process is the pretence that Palestinians and Israelis are two equal sides, equally at fault, equally responsible – thus erasing from view the brutal reality that Palestinians are an occupied, colonised people, dispossessed at the hands of one of the most powerful militaries on earth.

For more than two decades, under the cover of this fiction, Palestinians have engaged in internationally-sponsored “peace talks” and other forms of dialogue, only to watch as Israel has continued to occupy, steal and settle their land, and to kill and maim thousands of people with impunity.

The Palestinian-led Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement (BDS) aims to change this dynamic. It puts the initiative back in the hands of Palestinians. The goal is to build pressure on Israel to respect the rights of all Palestinians by ending its occupation and blockade of the West Bank and Gaza Strip; respecting the rights of Palestinian refugees who are currently excluded from returning to their homes just because they are not Jews; and abolishing all forms of discrimination against Palestinian citizens of Israel.

Abunimah ends with a prediction:

When we look back in a few years, Hawking’s decision to respect BDS may be seen as a turning point – the moment when boycotting Israel as a stance for justice went mainstream.

What is clear today is that his action has forced Israelis – and the rest of the world – to understand that the status quo has a price. Israel cannot continue to pretend that it is a country of culture, technology and enlightenment while millions of Palestinians live invisibly under the brutal rule of bullets, bulldozers and armed settlers.

This Real News video provides a valuable visual summary of the Hawking boycott action:

If Israel is to have the future it desires, then Israel’s friends must firmly tell them:  “Give me your car keys; friends don’t let friends drive drunk”.  Ali Abunimah provides the text we need to set that axiom in motion:

Israel cannot continue to pretend that it is a country of culture, technology and enlightenment while millions of Palestinians live invisibly under the brutal rule of bullets, bulldozers and armed settlers.”

As they used to say in the American South where I grew up: “That will preach, brothers and sisters”.

The picture of Hawkin, above, is from Wikimedia Commons. It appeared in the Scientific American.

About wallwritings

From 1972 through 1999, James M. Wall was editor and publisher of the Christian Century magazine, based in Chicago, lllinois. He was a Contributing Editor of the Century from 1999 until July, 2017. He has written this blog, wall writings.me, since it was launched April 27, 2008. If you would like to receive Wall Writings alerts when new postings are added to this site, send a note, saying, Please Add Me, to jameswall8@gmail.com Biography: Journalism was Jim's undergraduate college major at Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia. He has earned two MA degrees, one from Emory, and one from the University of Chicago, both in religion. He is an ordained United Methodist clergy person. He served for two years in the US Air Force, and three additional years in the USAF reserve. While serving on active duty with the Alaskan Command, he reached the rank of first lieutenant. He has worked as a sports writer for both the Atlanta Journal and Constitution, was editor of the United Methodist magazine, Christian Advocate for ten years, and editor and publisher of the Christian Century magazine for 27 years. James M Wall died March 22, 2021 at age 92. His family appreciates all of his readers, even those who may have disagreed with his well-informed writings.
This entry was posted in Human Rights, Middle East Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Hawking Stuns Israel With Conference Boycott

  1. Noushin Framke says:

    How not to cross a picket line, by Stephen Hawking. Thank you, Mr. Hawking! And as an aside, I went to the Beinart/Dershowitz debate last week at CUNY, NYC, where Dershowitz called the greatest scientist of our day an “ignoramus.” Talk about making yourself look small!

  2. Peace, Eqaulity, Liberty for All says:

    Thanks Jim for this expose. Professor Hawking not only showed courage
    and defiance but his true feeling against the cruelty and injustice the Israeli
    governments throughout the years, practiced on the Palestinians under occupation. Not only truth prevails, but also Freedom and justice will prevail
    when all human beings of conscience act like the courageous Professor
    We hope former President Clinton will follow suit, since he decried the occupation in 1998 when he visited Gaza and Bethlehem as a messenger of Peace along with then First lady Hillary Clinton, who said “the Palestinians
    deserve a state of their own”. What they said then and what they did after
    are two different practices. Pres. Clinton is applauded as one of the greatest
    statements in the United States history. Let us hope he will realize the Peace
    Prize is for those who do not support apartheid, instead they support human
    rights and an independent Palestinian State as legitimate as the USA or
    any other free state on the globe.
    There should be no double standard by anyone when it comes to Peace in
    the Middle East. If x=y, and y=z, then x=z. a valid theory.

    Let us hope more invited guests will cancel their participation to the
    conference on the same merits Prof. Hawking did, and prove to the wolrd
    they are courageous enough too.

  3. Art Preisinger says:

    Hawking’s boycott of the conference may spur the push for the release of Palestinian academic, Ahmed Qatamesh, who is falsely imprisoned in Israel.
    Let us hope so

  4. AWAD PAUL SIFRI says:

    Thank you for an excellent review, Jim. This is a formidable story that our mercenary-media and politicians tried to snuff out and keep under the radar screen.
    Let us not allow mainstream media the pleasure of a “one-time news story” that disappears in the ultra-deep sink hole of colonial Zionist deception.

    Like many thousands of people around the world, I salute Stephen Hawking for his brave and electric stand that has Israel’s Apartheid regime scrambling like a chicken the head of which was snapped.

    “Hawking Against Apartheid & Occupation” brings the shivers to Israel’s “Spin & Deception Pundits”, as well as, to Israel’s Apartheid-colonial-expansionist-nuclear-armed regime itself.

    The best thing all supporters of justice, freedom, peace and human dignity can do is to relentlessly promote BDS and to: SPREAD THE WORD; SPREAD THE WORD; SPREAD THE WORD; SPREAD THE WORD.

  5. William Gepford says:

    Thank you Jim, for the report and we should all thank Hawking for his bravery, in spite of his having ALS, to “speak” so profoundly truth to power. May this be the moment we have all prayed for.

  6. Pingback: Stephen Hawking Stuns Israel With Conference Boycott By James Wall | Eslkevin's Blog

  7. Jim, this is a vintage wallwriting. Thank you. I was immensely pleased, when I chanced to link to the “Eslkevin’s Blog” entry at the end of the comments area to find that Eslkevin had taken “Hawking Stuns…” from an Op-Ed News posting of it. I don’t peruse OEN as often as I should, but I think it’s a significant coup that you made its vetting process; I’ve always respected OEN and believe that it has an extensive readership! I may be too effusive: it may be that you’re regularly featured on OEN, but this is my first awareness of the good news. (OEN, I think, “ranks” its offerings by reader reaction, and I suggest that all reading this note go to it and rate Jim’s piece as (e.g.) “Valuable”; “News”; “Interesting”; etc. I did so and also chose to enter a comment at the OEN site; it was under moderation as I left the site. By taking these supportive actions, we can cause OEN to elevate “Hawking Stuns…” in its pecking order, giving it visibility and far more potential readers. Pro-Palestinian activists need all the visibility that can be mustered….)

  8. Pingback: “Poor George, he can’t help it . . .” | Wallwritings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s