A regular reader wrote recently and asked why I write so often about Palestine and Israel.
It was a good question and after some time for reflection I have an answer for him, inspired by a 1971 Johnny Cash song, “The Man in Black”.
Cash had been asked why he always wore black. He explains that he did so because he identifies with the poor and the hungry, the prisoners, the lonely and the old, and those who are dying in a war in a distant land, at that time, the Vietnam War.
A few years later, after “The Man In Black” became a best-selling album, Cash said:
“With the Vietnam War as painful in my mind as it was in most other Americans’, I wore it ‘in mournin’ for the lives that could have been.’ … Apart from the Vietnam War being over, I don’t see much reason to change my position … The old are still neglected, the poor are still poor, the young are still dying before their time, and we’re not making many moves to make things right. There’s still plenty of darkness to carry off.”
The Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, and our American wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan, are today providing “plenty of darkness”. Together, these wars are today’s Vietnam.
I am aware that I cannot sing, or write simple, powerful poetry as Cash has done. But I must write about the darkness that covers our nation as it continues its pursuit of empirical conquest at a tremendous cost at home, under the guise of “fighting terror”. Indeed, “terrorism” is today’s version of the Communism that Nixon and Kissinger used as their excuse for “defending” South Vietnam in the 1960s and 1970s.
Johnny Cash originally recorded “The Man in Black” before a college audience in May, 1971, one year after the Kent State Massacre when, during a student protest against the invasion of Cambodia, Ohio national guardsmen fired 67 rounds over a period of 13 seconds, killing four students and wounding nine others, one of whom suffered permanent paralysis.
In May, 1971, Richard Nixon and his Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, were still conducting a secret war, the details of which were only fully revealed on June 30, 1971, when the US Supreme Court ruled that the federal government could not prevent the publication of the Pentagon Papers in the New York Times.
The story of how those Papers were finally published in the Times is vividly presented in the 2010 documentary, The Most Dangerous Man in America. The title refers to Daniel Ellsberg, the Harvard professor who courageously risked his freedom to deliver the Pentagon Papers to the Times.
Henry Kissinger, who once taught with Ellsburg at Harvard, bitterly described his former academic colleague as “the most dangerous man in America.”
Ellsberg writes of his experiences in his 2002 book, Secrets: A Memoir of Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers.
Along with the vast majority of the American public, Johnny Cash was unaware of the Vietnam war narrative which Nixon and Kissinger tried to keep secret, when he wrote the lyrics for “The Man in Black”. What he did know was that young Americans and many Vietnamese were dying needlessly.
The lyrics are at the end of this post.
Today, with wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, the West Bank Bank and Gaza our military forces, and our surrogate Israeli military forces, are involved in an overall war against what a previous American president misnamed as “the global war on terror”.
This 2010 midterm election have essentially ignored the thousands and hundreds of thousands who are dying in distant lands because of our wars. Instead, public attention is riveted on the craziness of the Tea Party candidates, some of whom may very well end up in the Congress.
The American public does not know about the Israeli settlers who set fire to a Palestinian girls’ school building near Nablus this past week. Juan Cole, whose Informed Comment blog is a flashing light of warning to the American public, tells the story of the attack on the school:
The phrase “ethnic cleansing” conjures up a swift, comprehensive act of expulsion. But in reality, moving a large population off its land is the death of a thousand cuts, a slow, inexorable process of stealing property, harassment, forcing people into a condition of malnutrition.
The Native Americans in the Americas, the Aborigines in Australia, and the Palestinians in Israel/Palestine were only sometimes forced off their land suddenly and en masse. The gradual processes told, in the long run.
The amazing thing about what is being done to the Palestinians in the Palestinian West Bank by Israeli illegal aliens is that it is happening in full view of the world, reported on by wire services, and yet remains invisible to Western publics.
The world reacts in horror when the Taliban in Afghanistan torch girls’ schools. But Israeli squatters just set fire to the store room of a Palestinian girls’ school, and the whole school would have gone up in flames if that warehouse had not been near a water main. The Israeli illegals left behind graffiti saying ‘regards from the hills.’
Cole also reports that earlier in October,
Israeli squatters set fire to a Palestinian mosque in Bethlehem.
[Also this autumn] there is the seasonal vandalism against olive trees in Palestinian orchards, which reached a fever pitch this year. The Israeli authorities prosecute few of these offenses and almost never hand down a punishment to an Israeli squatter.
The 10 million olive trees in the West Bank and Gaza, occupying some 45 percent of the farmland, are the matrix of Palestinian existence. An attack on olive trees is a form of economic warfare of the first water.
The American public knows far more about the fumbling responses of the Republican candidate for Joe Biden’s old Delaware senate seat, than it does about the needless death of a 2-year-old Gaza child who was prevented by the Israeli army from traveling the short distance outside Gaza for specialized treatment. The Palestinian organization, Physicians for Human Rights, has that story on its website:
Nasma Abu Lasheen died on Saturday, October 16, 2010 in Gaza. Israel failed to issue her an urgent entry permit for life-saving medical treatment at Ha-Emek Medical Center in Afula, Israel. She was two years old.
Abu Lasheen, a young resident of Gaza diagnosed with Leukemia, was referred for emergency treatment in Israel on October 6, 2010. When requests to the Israeli Army for an entry permit went unanswered for several days, by way of B’tselem, the family contacted Physicians for Human Rights- Israel (PHR-Israel) for additional help.
That very same day, on October 13, 2010, PHR-Israel contacted the Gaza District Coordination Office (DCO) demanding a permit be issued immediately to the baby and her father to enable their entry into Israel. A military approval was finally granted the next afternoon, October 14, 2010.
Abu Lasheen’s medical condition had been deteriorating rapidly and by the time the permit was received, the treating doctor in Gaza, Dr. Mohammad Abu Sha’aban, said she was too sick to travel. Nasma died in the early morning hours of October 16, 2010.
Ziad Abbas works for the Middle East Children’s Alliance on a project to bring clean water to the children of Palestine. He grew up in Palestine. He writes in Counter Punch, that his work is especially personal to him because of his own childhood experiences of growing up deprived of water.
Israel controls and uses 89% of the water resources in the West Bank, leaving 11% for the 2.5 million Palestinians. The Israeli Occupation continues to limit Palestinian access to clean water as form of collective punishment by controlling the water resources and distribution and by destroying the water that we are able to get.
During Israeli military incursions, and especially during curfews, when we could not leave our homes, Israeli soldiers would shoot the water storage tanks on our roofs. Our water would pour down the sides of our buildings unused.
During the recent attack on Gaza, Israel targeted the entire water infrastructure including the largest water purification system in Gaza. They also targeted electrical generators that supported water purification and sewage treatment.
I write about these things because American churches are still hung up on not offending their Jewish neighbors, thus choosing interfaith harmony over justice.
I write about these things because major denominational meetings, like this past summer’s General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church, USA, dickered and delayed and finally decided to study further how they might best deal with the “problems” in the Middle East.
Since that Presbyterian GA meeting, two-year-old Abu Lasheen died waiting for permission to travel to an Israeli hospital. Since that meeting, Israeli settlers set fire to a Palestinian girls school, leaving behind graffiti on the wall that said, “regards from the hills”. Something about the insensitive arrogance of that graffiti implies there was not enough room on the wall to add, in Clint Eastwoodian fashion, “we’ll be back.”
I write about the American media’s blindness to the narrative of the suffering in Palestine because Tom Friedman continues to fool his liberal readers by pretending to criticize Israel when his criticism always includes the AIPAC approved list of what he insists are “facts”, but which are either outright lies or distortions of reality.
The most recent example was Friedman’s October 20 column which calls on Israel to help President Obama line up world opposition to Iran by reaching a friendly agreement with Palestinian negotiators.
Friedman opens his column with a set of “stubborn facts” which are really just a repeat of the acceptable Israeli narrative which, of course, he assures his readers are “stubborn facts”. Only, they are not.
Here is the start of Thomas Friedman’s latest column, followed by corrections:
Say what you want about Israel’s obstinacy at times, it remains the only country in the United Nations that another U.N. member, Iran, has openly expressed the hope that it be wiped off the map. And that same country, Iran, is trying to build a nuclear weapon.
Israel is the only country I know of in the Middle East that has unilaterally withdrawn from territory conquered in war — in Lebanon and Gaza — only to be greeted with unprovoked rocket attacks in return.
Indeed, if you want to talk about spoiled children, there is no group more spoiled by Iran and Syria than Hezbollah, the Lebanese Shiite militia.
Hezbollah started a war against Israel in 2006 that brought death, injury and destruction to thousands of Lebanese — and Hezbollah’s punishment was to be rewarded with thousands more missiles and millions more dollars to do it again. These are stubborn facts.
Friedman’s “stubborn facts” are stubborn, alright. They are falsehoods or distortions he clings to “stubbornly”.
Iran’s President Ahmedinejad never used the phrase, “wipe Israel off the map”. That was an initial mistranslation into English which the media loved and never let go. The media has refused, as Friedman does here, to go back and obtain the original statement by Ahmedinejad in a speech he gave to a Persian audience.
The Iranian president was quoting an ancient statement by Iran’s first Islamist leader, the late Ayatollah Khomeini, when he said that “this regime occupying Jerusalem must vanish from the page of time” just as the Shah’s regime in Iran had vanished.
He was not making a military threat. He was calling for an end to the occupation of Jerusalem at some point in the future. The “page of time” phrase suggests he did not expect it to happen soon. There was no implication that either Khomeini, when he first made the statement, or Ahmadinejad, in repeating it, felt it was imminent, or that Iran would be involved in bringing it about.
Another error: It is true that Israel took its military forces out of Lebanon and Gaza, but it did so because the cost in Israeli lives had become too expensive to maintain the garrisons in those two areas.
The invasions had proved to be a major loss for the vastly superior Israeli forces, a fact Friedman ignores as he praises Israel for its “unilateral withdrawal” from the two countries it had invaded and failed to control.
Friedman writes that “Hezbollah started a war against Israel in 2006 that brought death, injury and destruction to thousands of Lebanese.”
Israel did launch a massive invasion of Lebanon in 2006, but who fired the first shot has been debated. Israeli sources have confirmed that Israel’s invasion plans were already on the drawing board when a border skirmish erupted, giving Israel the excuse it wanted to launch a war that, indeed, “brought death, injury and destruction to thousands of Lebanese.”
Who brought those deaths, injuries and destruction to the Lebanese? Israel, of course.
Careful research would quickly demonstrate to Friedman and every other pro-Israel pundit and politician that Friedman’s “stubborn facts” are either false or distorted.
I will continue to write on Israel and Palestine as long as pundits like Thomas Friedman have access to the pages of the New York Times, and the American public remains ignorant of the actual facts on the ground in Israel and Palestine.
The Man in Black, lyrics by Johnny Cash
Well, you wonder why I always dress in black, Why you never see bright colors on my back, And why does my appearance always have a somber tone. Well, there’s a reason for the things that I have on.
I wear the black for the poor and the beaten down, Livin’ in the hopeless, hungry side of town, And I wear it for the prisoner who has long paid for his crime, But still is there because he’s a victim of the times.
I wear the black for those who never read, Or listened to the words that Jesus said, About the road to happiness through love and charity, Why, you’d think He’s talking straight to you and me.
Well, we’re doin’ mighty fine, I do suppose, In our streak of lightnin’ cars and fancy clothes, But just so we’re reminded of the ones who are held back, Up front there ought ‘a be a Man In Black.
I wear it for the sick and lonely old, For the reckless ones whose bad trip left them cold, I wear the black in mornin’ for the lives that could have been, Each week we lose a hundred fine young men.
And, I wear it for the thousands who have died, Believen’ that the Lord was on their side, And I wear it for another hundred thousand who have died, Believen’ that we all were on their side.
Well, there’s things that never will be right I know, And things need changin’ everywhere you go, But ’til we start to make a move to make a few things right, You’ll never see me wear a suit of white.
Ah, I’d love to wear a rainbow every day, To tell the world that everything’s OK, But mabe I can carry off a little darkness on my back,
‘Till things are brighter, I’m the Man In Black.
The photo at the top of the page is of two Bedouin girls, in school uniform, returning to their houses after a school day in Abu Farda near the West Bank city of Qalqilia on October 6, 2010. MaanImages/Khaleel Reash.
The Youtube above, and the lyrics by Johnny Cash may be found at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qLkmC2VuXA8.
Thank goodness for clear-thinking writers and observers like you who are not beholden to anything or anyone but the truth. pundits like Friedman and the like not only can’t see the forest for the trees, they are providing more and more trees to obfuscate and obscure the truth. It’s not easy to discern what is really going on but your writing is a beacon in the wilderness. Keep the light shining on this horrible darkness.
What you have said, Jim, should hurt us all. I have been convinced for several years now that the Israel/Palestine problem is that Christians have forgotten who(se) they are. Mark Bravermen’s new book, Fatal Embrace, forthrightly identifies the core problem: when asked by his wife, “are you becoming Christian?,” he said “No, I am becoming Jewish” (p. 44). And because of that change in him, he fights more tirelessly for justice for Palestinians, and for Jews in Israel. Rabbi Jesus, my leader, spoke about injustice of the religious system of his time but the religious power structure refused to listen. Hebrew prophets also spoke of the injustuces of their time, words of which fell on deaf ears. If Christians took seriously being disciples of rabbi Jesus, there would be a transformative sea-change in the Middle East.
Thank you for writing this. I have personally seen for myself while spending three months in Palesine how many Israeli-Palestinian houses were splattered with grafiti and signs which says, “A good Arab is a dead Arab”, and other racist signs. I saw IDF soldiers putting stink bombs on Palestinian school children’s backpacks and lunchboxes that were gathered outside the Cordoba School in Hebron. I attended a conference with a panel of members of the Israeli Physicians for Human Rights and the Red Crescent in Ramallah where Palestinian ambulance drivers were describing incidents when they were not only experiencing harassments at checkpoints, but where there were instances where some of their fellow drivers were killed by Israeli soldiers while driving patients in their ambulances.
Throughout my stay in Israel, I had the distinct impression that Israelis accept Palestinians only if they are willing to be subservient and serve the people of Israel.
These indignities and inhumane treatment against Palestinians must stop. May God have mery on us all, if we do not stop these injustices and work towards an end to the occupation now!
Thanks for your torch of Freedom, Jim. It lights up what America and Western Christianity stood for, once upon a time.
Israel’s deliberate slow Medieval torture, destruction, slaughter, eviction, terroristic savaging of Palestinian people, homes, schools, pre-Hebrew excavations, olive trees, school children, women, elderly, young, sick, hungry, thirsty souls goes on daily and with a goal of arriving at the “Palestinian Solution”, through “stealth measures” and “silencer-anti-truth stun guns.
The vast majority of our churshes are more concerned about their Baal idols. The false excuses of remaining “micely”-silent because of European crimes against Jews half a century ago is mind stagerring and heart-stopping. They act like the Pharisees and have sold their Christianity to false prophets-for-profits.
Many thanks to Mr. Wall. His great, realistic piece of writing came to my computer today, after my mail carrier had delivered CMEP (Churches for Middle East Peace)’s latest pap on the search for “peace” in the Holy Land. CMEP never ceases to place the two vastly unequal parties on an exactly equal footing — citing Israel’s “security” needs followed by a hope that the Palestinians have a chance for “dignity and viability.” A worthless organ, is CMEP, and a shame to “Jesus Christ” Christianity, even as it arrogates its access to the White House and Congress….
As to the Zionist shill Friedman, I finally had my fill of his glib slickness in August or September 2005, when he sneered — following Sharon’s extraction of illegal settler-colonists and their military guard from Gaza without by any stretch ending the illegal occupation of that beleaguered Strip — the equivalent of “Okay, Gazans, you’re free: go for it — build yourselves a Dubai on the Mediterranean.” Right….
Jim: Keep up your excellent writing about Palestine and Israel. There is, alas, very little objective reporting on the subject of Israel and Palestine by the mainline American press. Your work is deeply appreciated. Harris
I have come to this issue much too late, but, nevertheless, I have come to it. Perhaps my turning point was being part of a team that pulled together a great conference earlier this year in Seattle WA as part of the Sabeel movement, at which I learned almost too much.
Perhaps it was due to the passion of my friend Dick Toll who heads up Friends of Sabeel – – North America. Since then I have read your postings and commentary. I have read accounts from Palestine. I have read recently the account of Rachel Corrie’s murder “trial”. All are fact. Cold but fact. This posting of your’s goes so much deeper for me than just fact.
At a very deep level, we all need to wear black.
Thank you for pointing this to me.
It was a legitimate question to which you provided a compelling response. Until there are a thousand Juan Coles, Glenn Greenwalds, Mark Bravermans, Jim Wall, and Ali Abunimahs, their voices on the inhumanity of the occupation and our country’s complicity in and financing of it will be needed.
Another quote from the dearly missed Man in Black, which the Churches would do well to recall: “How well I have learned that there is no fence to sit on between heaven and hell. There is a deep, wide gulf, a chasm, and in that chasm is no place for any man.”
Thanks Jim for pounding away at the accepted, assumed, unquestioned narrative for the sake of a narrative hardly anyone knows. The Israel Palestine Mission Network of the Presbyterian Church (USA) continues to do everything it can to move its denomination to hear and understand the Palestinian narrative and take substantive stands against Israeli occupation and apartheid. It is a long, slow, painful process which is why we need folks like you getting the word out nonstop.
Thanks, Jim Wall. You give us evidence, upon evidence, upon evidence!
What incredible words by Johnny Cash, “The Man in Black.”
Besides Braverman’s book, “Fatal Embrace”, I recommend also Avraham Burg’s book, “The Holocast is Over, Let us Rise From its Ashes”, and Ilan Pappe’s book, “The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine.” The latter is an excellent expose’ of the Zionist plan since 1948, which continues to this day.
I recommend Susan Albuhawa’s “Mornings in Jenin”. It is different literary approach and reminds me of the impact of Paton’s “Cry the Beloved Country” in the days of struggle against apartheid. The struggle for Palestinian justice needs to find the kind of heart that can grab people: “Cry the Beloved Country” as well as describing the Kairos document, “A Moment of Truth: A word of faith, hope and love from the heart of Palestinian suffering” as the Palestinian “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” are good approaches. We have to grab both hearts and minds…
I have long advocated that Palestinians be given their God-given right to exist in a meaningful way. This has not been done by the israelis and i will continue to do all I can that it may happen!!
(Sorry, I’m too late for this one. ) Facts are welcome, it’s edifying to read truth, but how to change US policy?
Never too late to comment. The postings remain on line forever,
You are also free to comment on the latest comment, just posted.