by James M. Wall
It did not take long for a group of opportunistic U.S. Governors to respond to the horrors of the Paris bombings.
They did so with racist, religiously bigoted responses against Muslims.
Their responses were degrading to their collective state offices, and hateful to a major world religion. They also display a collective naked ignorance of the fact that governors have absolutely nothing to do with U.S. immigration policy.
Time reports the reactions of these governors:
“In the wake of the attacks on Paris, a slew of American governors have expressed opposition to President Obama’s plan to allow 10,000 Syrian refugees to come to the U.S. Some states (like Alabama and Texas) say they would not allow these immigrants into their states; some (like Massachusetts and Nevada) have requested more information from the federal government before they make a decision; and others (like Idaho and North Carolina) land in the middle, saying they oppose the idea but stopping short of refusing to receive refugees. On the other end of the spectrum, a handful of governors have pledged to accept Syrian migrants.”
Think Progress delivers the ignorance memo to the governors:
“There is no lawful means that permits a state government to dictate immigration policy to the president in this way. As the Supreme Court explained in Hines v. Davidowitz, ‘the supremacy of the national power in the general field of foreign affairs, including power over immigration, naturalization and deportation, is made clear by the Constitution.” States do not get to overrule the federal government on matters such as this one.”
Did the governors miss examining Hines v. Davidowitz in their collective rush to join the anti-Muslim lynch mobs?
Faced with a crucial test of leadership, many of the nation’s governors failed. Take note of their names and determine if this is leadership, or flashbacks to the years of the Ku Klux Klan.
Among the names is Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, who has just withdrawn as a Republican presidential candidate. (Pictured)
Governor Jindal issued an executive order on Monday authorizing his government “to utilize all lawful means” to block Syrian refugees from resettling in the state. He also instructed and authorized state police “to utilize all lawful means to monitor and avert threats within the State of Louisiana” if notified of Syrian refugees already living in the state.
Responses from leaders of states in “the land of the free and the home of the brave” were echoed in this summary from Huffington Post:
Huffington Post reports
“More than half of the nation’s governors have called on the U.S. to stop admitting Syrian refugees, most of them promising to do everything in their power to prevent them from entering their states.
“The governors represent Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and Wisconsin. All are Republicans except for Maggie Hassan of New Hampshire, a Democrat.
“While most pledged to block Syrian refugees from entering their states, Florida Gov. Rick Scott said he doesn’t think he has the authority to keep the federal government from resettling them. Hassan called for the U.S. to stop admitting Syrian refugees entirely, but her spokesman said she could not block their resettlement in New Hampshire. Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin similarly said there should be a moratorium on admitting Syrian refugees but stopped short of saying her state would try to reject them.”
“Instead of leading their citizens during an ugly time of suffering and death, these governors chose to take political advantage of a tragic series of events by displaying their own ignorance, bigotry to deceive, knowingly or not, those they were chosen to lead.”
Unfortunately, this isn’t anything new. Only this time the governors have moved to the front of the lynch mobs.
“Muslim-blaming is a now expected reaction to any terrorism attack in the U.S. or abroad. Even though less than 2 percent of all terrorist attacks over the past five years have been “religiously motivated,” and only 6 percent of all terrorism attacks in the U.S. between 1980 and 2005 were committed by Muslims, a few events — 9/11, in particular — have spread a healthy dose of Islamophobia across the country over the past few decades.
“At the same time, the population of Muslims in the U.S. has grown to more than 2.6 million. Many of them arrived in North America hoping to escape the discrimination and hate already brewing in their home country, only to be met with rampant discrimination.”
Islamophobia greets them in their new homeland, whether they have been here for generations, or for a few years.
“Researchers are just beginning to explore the kind of toll that Islamophobia can take on the mental and physical health of Muslim-Americans — and it’s unsurprisingly harsh.
“Studies have shown that many Muslims not only experience religious discrimination in their daily lives, but are fully aware of their devalued position in society,” writes a group of Norwegian psychology professors in a 2012 study. Their own study found that perceived Islamophobia has a “distinct effect on Muslim minorities’ health and identification.”
“Of the few studies on Muslim health that exist, most identified that daily, repetitive harassment as the biggest factor contributing to long-term mental health issues in Muslim populations.”
The governors have allowed the murderous conduct of an organized terror organization to serve as an excuse to condemn all Muslims as a danger.
Bigotry is far reaching into the entrails of a land that has always harbored the disease of racial and religious bigotry. It is now officially out in the open in the sickening images of governors fighting to join the mob.
Western Muslim communities are fast becoming the target of violent and racist threats.
“The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) is investigating several threats against mosques as potential hate crimes, according to the advocacy group the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR).
“CAIR’s Florida chapter reported two separate calls to mosques in the state over the past several days that threaten to bomb or shoot up the places of worship. For instance, just hours after the attacks in France on Friday night, a mosque in St. Petersburg, Florida received a voicemail from a man who said he planned to shoot Muslims, including children.. . .
“In Orange County, Florida, a Muslim family found three bullet holes on the side of their home this weekend. According to the incident report, they told the police they suspect people are retaliating against them in the aftermath of the Paris attacks. Mahmoud Elmasri and his family were not home at the time because they were “out painting pictures of peace for the victims of the attacks in France,” the Orlando Sentinel reports.
“In Michigan, police have been investigating an individual who posted a threatening message to Muslims on Twitter after news broke that ISIS had claimed responsibility for the violence in France. “Dearborn, MI has the highest Muslim population in the United States. Let’s [expletive] that place up and send a message to ISIS. We’re coming,” the individual tweeted on Saturday night. Cops in Dearborn say the person is ‘no longer a threat’.
“CAIR says these threats ‘fit a pattern of increased hate-motivated crimes and bias incidents nationwide targeting persons and property associated, or perceived to be associated, with Islam and the American Muslim community’.
The Obama administration plans to admit 10,000 Syrian refugees this fiscal year, all of whom will undergo security screenings that typically take 18 to 24 months.
President Obama has sharply criticized governors and citizens alike for this response to Syrians seeking safety in the U.S., saying it is ‘shameful’ to reject Muslim refugees and noting that Americans “don’t have religious tests to our compassion.”
In the picture above, Imam Suleimaan Hamed, the leader of the Atlanta Masjid of Al Islam mosque, walks through the mosque, in Atlanta. It is an AP photo by Branden Camp. The picture of Governor Jindal is a Getty photo by Joe Raedle.
Thank you, Jim. Please add me to your list. Kathy
Ignorance is not necessary for bigotry, but “it helps”. It is truly amazing that the GOP, especially those far right of the party, those who espouse Christianity, would take the most “unchristian” posture. I suggest they read chapter 23 of Mathew’s gospel as well as chapter 10 of Luke’s gospel. For those less “religiously inclined” I suggest reading the inscription on the Statue of Liberty.
In the “entrails.” The word was well chosen, Jim. Thank you for speaking out against these opportunistic racists–probably acting out of fear of the other as well as their opportunism. Looks like we need to get back down and educate the ignorant. Kudos.
Thank you, Jim, for saying it as it is – as is always the case.
The irresponsible scare tactics incited by many of our politicians and media are truly pathetic and cowardly, and dangerous.
When critics used to ask how could a country as advanced as Germany produce a Hitler, and how did the German people follow such a leader and commit such atrocities, people were in utter disbelief. Could this ever happen in the US?
Yesterday, President Obama did a most eloquent and an outstanding job, at the G-2 Meeting, in Turkey, by rejecting such shameless bigotry, and so did President Bush before him right after 9-11. They both very clearly explained the differences between extremist terrorists and the mainstream group they belong to, at least in name.
However, those politicians running for office, and our mainstream media are intentionally using incitement as a cowardly tactic. But, scare tactics and ignorance, added to bigotry and racism, make a dangerous mix.
Beware of emotional appeals to our bleeding hearts. Suicidal altruism and destructive do-goodism are not generosity but something else. The President does not have statutory discretion to admit refugees here in question under the United States Refugee Act of 1980. Call me bigoted and ignorant if you must, but I stand with the twenty-six governors. The first lesson of history is that man is territorial, and any government ignoring this law of nature flirts with revolution and disorder. There is an urgent need for inquiry and judgment concerning just what we are being asked to accept. It would be wiser for the United States to terminate attempts to overthrow Assad on demand of the Israeli government, which is the root cause of the current crisis. Excess immigration into any country is highly dangerous, and a fair illustration is the excess immigration into Palestine after 1939. — John Remington Graham of the Minnesota Bar (#3664X).
The Governors are simply posturing.
Clearly, the United States is largely responsible for the civil war in Syria and the rise of ISIL. There are still stores which post signs, saying: “You break it, YOU own it.” But I guess Obama has forgotten this form of justice.
We’ve tried bombing in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Libya, Somalia, and a few other places. Has this brought peace OR justice? It worked so well in Viet Nam, Cambodia, and Laos!
REAL leadership would cancel the largest weapons sale in history to Saudi Arabia, the number two instigator of terrorism in the Middle East. We could stop providing Saudi Arabia weapons and intelligence support in Yemen. We could stop making Israel our Number One foreign aid recipient, providing this poor country with the money to buy more weapons from us. We could take a look at our policy of “regime change.” Has this EVER worked?
Oh! I see! It might work the next time!